CABC Homepage
New Customer | Sign In
List of Popular Cases Newly Released Cases Faculty of Business and Economics Institutional Users Home Site Map
Advanced Search
Topic Index
Industry & Company Index
Most Popular Cases
Newly Released Cases
SME Cases Series
China Cases Series
India Cases Series
IT Industry Transformation Series
Cases in Chinese
Cases in Other Languages
Project SARS Rebound
Case Details:
Email to a friend
China Metal Recycling Holdings Limited: Scrap King Gets Scrapped  
Product Ref: 14/548C Company: China Metal Recycling Holdings Limited

Product Type: Case Industry: Diversified Metals and Mining

Related Product(s): Teaching Note
Authors: Amy Lau   Jun Han   Katrina Tai
China Metal Recycling Holdings Ltd (¡§CMR¡¨ or ¡§the Company¡¨) was said to be the largest scrap metal recycling company in mainland China. It was listed on the Hong Kong Stock Exchange in June 2009. For a few years after its initial listing, the Company reported extremely high revenue and profit growth. Many investment houses assigned its stock ¡§buy¡¨ or ¡§strong buy¡¨ recommendations. This optimistic situation lasted until January 2013, when California-based Glaucus Research Group issued a report pointing out that, in comparison with other publically available industry data, CMR¡¦s reported sales figures were unlikely to be true. This rang the regulatory alarm bell. The Securities and Futures Commission of Hong Kong (¡§SFC¡¨) conducted an investigation and found reporting fraud. On July 29, 2013, the SFC obtained court orders appointing provisional liquidators to take over the Company. CMR was suspended from trading on main board of the Hong Kong Stock Exchange. Several of the Company¡¦s key directors and officers were arrested in the next couple of weeks.

The information provided in the Company¡¦s annual reports complied with Hong Kong listing requirements and financial reporting standards. It apparently had sound corporate governance structures. For three and a half consecutive years, its external auditor, a leading international accounting firm, had given its financial statements ¡§true and fair¡¨ marks. With all these seeming positives, investors were easily misled. How can investors uncover such camouflaged financial fraud? What are the key risk areas one should focus on when analyzing a company? How can a company¡¦s financials be double-checked using publically available information?
Functional Area : Accounting & Control

Learning Objective: This case has the objective of demonstrating how to discover fraud, while highlighting the following:
1. Provide a basic understanding of financial-report fraud, particularly where there are such typical red flags as:
Improbable growth rate; Improbable revenue per employee figures; Improbable inventory turnover compared with peers; Improbable return on capital not in line with the business involved; Abnormal resignations and moves by top company officials.
2. Examine the difference between corporate governance ¡§on paper¡¨ and corporate governance as actually implemented.
3. Examine the role of regulators in financial markets.
4. Emphasize the importance of professional ethics.
5. Identify the role of short-sellers in financial markets.
Length: 25 pages Country: China (People's Rep. of)
Hong Kong SAR

Pub. Year: 2014 Level of Difficulty: 2
This product type is available in the following language(s):      English
Related Information: N/A
Order This Item
Type Language Quantity * Unit Price
Case (14/548C) HK$58 / US$7.5
* Order quantity should include copies that you plan to make
   for class use or distribute for other purposes.
   You will not be shipped hard copies for cases.